Concord E-Discovery, Scanning & Data Collection

Southern California's Finest for 25 years & counting

Request a Free Professional Consultation  (213) 745-3175
eDiscovery · Scanning · Forensic Data Collection · Online Attorney Review · Printing
Serving top law firms and corporations since 1996  
  • About Us
    • Meet Concord
    • Our Blog
    • Testimonials
  • Services
    • Deposition Officer Services
    • Records Storage
    • Financial Printing
    • Managed Services
  • E-Discovery
    • Venio On-Line Review
    • Online Review
    • Data Collection
    • ESI Calculator
  • On-Site
  • Scanning
  • Legal Copying
    • Trial Exhibit Binders
  • Records Storage
  • Contact Us

If you want to avoid sanctions, hire an ediscovery consultant!

February 10, 2015

Don’t take chances, avoid sanctions & hire an ediscovery consultant

Accessible v. Inaccessible Data

Brown v. FPI Mgmt, No. 4:11-cv-5414 YGR (KAW), 2013 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 1040 (N.D. Cal. Jan. 3, 2013)The Federal Rules of Civil Procedure were updated almost a decade ago to include rules regarding the production of ESI, but the case law involving the discovery of ESI is still maturing. Many litigants producing documents in litigation are still trying the old “my system isn’t good enough to find the documents” defense.  However the Courts are starting to become wary of such defenses and in the above captioned matter, defendant producer’s argument that producing requested documents was unduly burdensome was rejected:

Defendant argued that it would be difficult to find responsive documents because 1) the terms “Community Director” and “Portfolio Manager” are commonly used in email signatures, 2) the term “promotion” is commonly used throughout emails, and 3) FPI’s email system is not capable of conducting advanced searches. But the Court rejected the argument because Defendant could have used other search terms, or simply sort through the emails, to find the responsive documents. By interviewing its employees or by consulting its own records, Defendant ought to be able to narrow its searches by the persons involved and the approximate dates. Although Defendant may not know how to efficiently conduct a search of its email system, that does not relieve it of its discovery obligations. It may need to utilize the assistance of IT personnel or obtain a consultant to help conduct the search.

Defendant did not provide the Court with an estimate of the cost or the amount of time needed for discovery, nor did it provide a declaration of an e-discovery expert to substantiate its assertion that the documents were not reasonably accessible. Accordingly, the Court held that Defendant did not make a good-faith effort to produce  responsive documents.

The court acknowledged that defendants might still find that the documents were not reasonably accessible.  But if that were the case, the court could still order sampling of the emails at issue, or it could permit plaintiffs to conduct discovery on the costs and burdens of providing the emails, or plaintiffs might have to share some of the costs.

Call today (800) 246-7881

 


Filed Under: Uncategorized Tagged With: California, consultant, data retention, ediscovery, ESI, kroll, litigation, los angeles, native production, relativity, sanctions, Technology assisted review

RSS Concord E-Discovery, Scanning & Data Collection

  • E-Discovery Managed Services: A Bridge to Predictive Analytics March 25, 2016
    When it comes to e-discovery, many firms have not integrated a fundamental analytics tool—predictive coding. Call CONCORD today! (800) 246-7881 Tania Mabrey and Monica Bay March 22, 2016 Although predictive analytics may be difficult to master, it’s a tool that can greatly improve litigation results. There’s no question that Big Data analytics are dramatically changing […]
  • Considering SaaS-Based E-Discovery? January 22, 2016
    Considering SaaS-Based E-Discovery? 8 Things to Know Before You Buy Call CONCORD today 10x Faster than the competition (800) 246-7881 Attorneys and law firm CIOs need to consider several areas before buying a cloud-based discovery solution. ©iStock.com/ChrisGorgio Each day it seems more e-discovery software options are coming in the form of cloud-based services. However, not […]

E-Discovery Services

Document Scanning

Legal Copying

Copyright © 2023 · Enterprise Pro Theme On Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in